Sound technical content, curated with aloha by
Ted Mooney, P.E. RET
Pine Beach, NJ
The authoritative public forum
for Metal Finishing since 1989
-----
Loss of brightness in nickel sulfamate bath
Q. I am conducting research on nickel electroforming using a sulfamate bath. We prepared a bath from standard liquid nickel sulfamate, boric acid, and nickel chloride, plus we added a wetting agent which is a commercial product so I do not know the chemical name for it. We use copper seed layer and an organic mold (thick photoresist) for plating. The size of our bath is quite small: only 11 liters.
The problem is that: Initially, we were able to deposit 15-20 microns-thick shiny-bright (mirror-like) nickel at 50 °C bath temperature and 80-100 ASF current density. After about 10 Amp.hour of operation, the color of the deposit started to turn to white-color, and the surface of the deposits looks like orange-skinned, instead of being shiny. I performed activated carbon treatment and re-add the wetting agent, but the result is still unchanged. Can it be due to metallic impurities? If so, does dummy plating helps, and what must be the dummy plating period and current density ?
A second question is, I plan to add saccharin to the solution as a brightening agent. But, when I add even 0.5 g/l saccharin to the bath, its pH drops dramatically below 3. How can I handle it?
My final question is, the cathode regions closer to the electrical contacts are coated much faster than the regions far away. I think this is related with insufficient leveling agent concentration. Can you recommend a leveling agent that can be used in the bath that I described above?
Said Emre ALPERMiddle East Technical University - Ankara, TURKEY
2003
A. Maybe there was a proprietary ingredient in your initial run called "beginner's luck" and it has become exhausted. Seriously, it is hard to tell why the quality of the deposit deteriorated so drastically, but I might make a wild guess that your pH went bad and your meter doesn't work, because I can't understand a tiny addition of saccharin causing the pH to actually plummet. Low current dummying may remove copper and other impurities, but it's hard to know why you would have developed serious contamination in a short period of operation. A leveling agent will help general brightness because it helps with micro-leveling, but it will not seriously improve metal distribution across the face of a part in nickel plating. PVC or polypropylene shields to divert current from the high current areas ought to work though. Ted Mooney, P.E. Striving to live Aloha finishing.com - Pine Beach, New Jersey 2003 A. Sulfamate nickel should be a very smooth matte surface. If it is shiny, it had a poison, either organic or inorganic, that plated out (or the equivalent), I.E.: the plate that you are now getting is normal (if I understood your description) For your final question, the rate of deposition is at the square root of the distance from the anode. You do not have a leveling problem, you have an anode placement problem. If you can not move the anode you will have to use a shield or a thief to reduce the high plating area. Using a lower current density (amperage) will also help slightly with the leveling. I have never used saccharin, but can not imagine, or ever heard of it having that pronounced effect on the pH. James Watts- Navarre, Florida 2003 |
Q. Hi,
In the last two days, I found out that the above problem seems to be due to burning of plated nickel. The symptoms that I learned matches with that. I lost the brightness first in the high-current density regions and then at low current density regions. In addition, the absence of nickel around electrical contact points also supports that the problem is burning. In the original bath, the boric acid concentration that I used was 20 g/l, and now I increased it to 32 g/l. The deposit quality is better now, but still there is grey-colored deposit at high-current density regions.
Do you have any idea about the consumption rate of Boric acid in nickel sulfamate baths? Can I add sulfamic acid ⇦this on eBay or Amazon [affil links] to keep pH low enough?
Said Emre Alper [returning]Middle East Technical University - Turkey
2003
A. I assume you are plating onto an organic or non conducting substrate and using the copper as a conducting layer. The photoresist is there to impart the desired pattern. It looks to me like you are using impure chemicals. The bath composition that you briefly describe may give a bright deposit with certain surfactants, but not all; since you do not know what it is, there is a problem here. Some surfactants can act as brighteners, but many do not, so you really need to know what you are using. Furthermore, if the initial solution contains impurities this too can act as a temporary brightener until it is depleted. I would suggest you make a new bath with known and pure chemicals. When you add the saccharin the bath will give a bright and hard deposit, but use sodium saccharin. Neither saccharin or sodium saccharin will reduce the pH, so I think the saccharin is either impure or totally mislabeled. As far as throwing power is concerned, you do not mention how big the cathodic surface area is, so you could be overloading the bath. Alternatively and more likely, the copper conducting layer is not as conducting as you hoped it was! It may have been burnt when you initially turned on the nickel current and contact has been jeopardized. Try using a much lower initial current (say 2-5 ASF) and slowly step-ramp it with time. Trevor Crichton R&D practical scientist Chesham, Bucks, UK 2003 A. Boric acid is basically not consumed. The biggest loss is dragout or it precipitated out when the temp was lowered. Gray in the LCD is almost always copper contamination. With a stripped piece of corrugated steel, apply 1-2 amps per square foot of cathode. This will plate out the copper in the recessed areas and not take out too much nickel. Certainly you control the pH with sulfamic acid. How else did you plan to do it since the pH rises with use. James Watts- Navarre, Florida 2003 |
adv.
"The Sulfamate Nickel How-To Guide"
by David Crotty, PhD
& Robert Probert
published Oct. 2018
$89 plus shipping
Q, A, or Comment on THIS thread -or- Start a NEW Thread