Sound technical content, curated with aloha by
Ted Mooney, P.E. RET
Pine Beach, NJ
The authoritative public forum
for Metal Finishing since 1989
-----
Problems with Kesternich test and Zn/Ni alloy finishing
Q. I would like to know if there has been any sulfur dioxide exposure (Kesternich test) testing done on alkaline zinc-nickel or CorroBan (Boeing) zinc-nickel (minimum 8 µm thick) electrodeposited coatings and hot dip galvanized coatings. We have parts that are galvanized, machined, and zinc-nickel plated to protect the machined areas. I know from extensive testing that, generally, parts that are galvanized and alkaline zinc-nickel plated have poor salt fog resistance compared to parts that are just plated over the plain steel or are chloride zinc plated (5 to 8 µm thick) followed by zinc-nickel. I've since become aware that, individually, both zinc and nickel are somewhat sensitive to sulfur corrosion. Up until this point, I was hoping to eliminate the galvanizing step and just go with the plating. I was wondering if the zinc-nickel alloy deposit with a yellow iridescent chromate would fare better in a sulfur atmosphere. Our parts are used in products that sit out in the field for 20 years or more. Our products see just about every type of atmospheric exposure there is; marine, rural, petroleum refining, heavy industrial, pulp and paper, etc. Any help or suggestions you can give me would be greatly appreciated.
Craig Whittle1996
1996
A. Hi, Craig.
Ed Budman [Bensalem, PA] of Dipsol-Gumm makes a circuit of presentations about alkaline zinc-nickel plating and its corrosion resistance. He is a true expert on it and I'll bet he has some data on sulfur-dioxide accelerated testing.
Ted Mooney, P.E.
Striving to live Aloha
finishing.com - Pine Beach, New Jersey
----
Ed. note: Sorry, Ed Budman has passed away since the time of this posting.
Thanks for the feedback Ted. I'm following up on your suggestions.
1996
2002
Q. Nowadays we are not able to pass 2 cycles in Kesternich test with a finish of alloy Zn/Ni of 12-15% of alloy to a thickness of 8 microns with yellow passivation, even if the pieces receive a seal after chromating. But in salt spray testing, the same pieces easily exceed 800 hours to red corrosion.
Can someone advise me on this problem.
Miguel Angel Martín
surface finishing shop
Madrid, Spain
A. My first suggestion is to put your parts in another test corrosion test chamber and see if your results are similar. My suggestion is to be sure your chromate film has sat at least 24 hours before corrosion testing, and that the parts haven't been handled.
Good Luck!
Karl Weyermann- Lebanon, Kentucky, USA
2002
2002
Q. Karl:
The results are similar in other corrosion chambers. Also, we always waited for 24 hours before doing any test of corrosion. I think that the problem is the bad general behavior of Zn/Ni to this type of test.
Miguel Angel Martín
surface finishing shop
Madrid, Spain
A. My third and fourth suggestions are to increase the plating thickness to improve corrosion and/or increase chromate exposure time. Also, I would take a look at basic water quality. Make-up water with significant amounts of sulfites and other unwanted materials can cause early corrosion failure.
Karl Weyermann- Lebanon, Kentucky, USA
2002
2002
Q. I bring you more difficulty Karl: The tests are similar with 25 microns of thickness, and passivation time greatly increased. The washing water is distilled.
A greeting, and thanks for your interest.
Miguel Angel Martín
surface finishing shop
Madrid, Spain
A. Here are a few more places to check out. Too high drying temperature or too long drying time will cause the chromate film to have less corrosion protection. Also metallic contamination of chromate solution or poor solution agitation can reduce the quality of your chromate film. Lastly, the roughness of your zinc deposit could be a factor.
Hope this helps and good luck.
Karl Weyermann- Lebanon, Kentucky
2002
Q. Hello,
I have the same problem, with Zn-Ni (12-15% Ni) parts that must pass 2 cycles of Sulfur dioxide corrosion resistance and are failing. We tried increasing the thickness, Cr3 passivate, and a sealant, and there is no significant improvement.
Did anyone find a solution to this problem ?
Plating - Oradea, Romania
March 13, 2020
A. The only way to get more Kesternich cycles is to increase the deposit thickness. Trivalent passivates (which generate hexavalent chromium to improve corrosion resistance) don't help at all in the Kesternich test because the hex chrome gets reduced to trivalent by the sulfur dioxide.
Tom Rochester
CTO - Jackson, Michigan, USA
Plating Systems & Technologies, Inc.
March 13, 2020
Q. Dear all,
we have some problems to pass Kesternich test (24h) on crimped fittings (brake system) coated with Zn-Ni (Cr3+ and Co free colorless passivation) 12-15% Ni / 10 microns with inorganic sealer. See picture attached.
What is your experience about this issue?
Alessandro Mondin- Olginate, Lecco, Italy
June 12, 2020
this text gets replaced with bannerText
Q, A, or Comment on THIS thread -or- Start a NEW Thread